The Pros and Cons of Congestion Pricing in Manhattan

Good morning. It’s Thursday. We’ll examine two words that transit advocates love and commuters who drive into Manhattan dread — congestion pricing. We’ll also look at takeaways from Tuesday’s primaries and special elections, especially for Democrats.

Credit…Gregg Vigliotti for The New York Times

This afternoon the Metropolitan Transportation Authority will hold a public a hearing. The four-page reminder the agency sent out a few days ago sounded dry.

The hearing could be about anything, but it will be about one of the most contentious topics facing New York City: congestion pricing.

Congestion pricing would reduce traffic in one of the world’s densest and busiest areas — from 60th Street to the Battery, minus the F.D.R. Drive and the West Side Highway — while bringing in $1 billion annually in badly needed revenue to help fund mass transit.

How many fewer cars? By the agency’s estimate, 27,500 fewer each day if the fee were set at $23, one of the price points the agency has suggested. At $9 or $10, the reduction would amount to some 12,000 cars a day.

Transit advocates say congestion pricing is overdue. “We face a crisis of congestion and crisis of a transit system desperately in need of funding,” said Cory Epstein, a spokesman for Transportation Alternatives, an advocacy group. “This plan will shift people from cars to sustainable ways to get around. We needed it yesterday.”

But it would add another expense for people who depend on cars to get to jobs in Manhattan — or people whose cars are their jobs.

“Especially for the yellow cab industry,” said Bhairavi Desai of the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, “this would be an existential threat.” She said that people who make a living driving taxis or ride-share vehicles “are looking down the barrel of massive job losses or indentured servitude to the M.T.A.” Her group held a rally on Wednesday outside Gov. Kathy Hochul’s Manhattan office.

Last month the transit agency appointed five people to a panel that will recommend toll rates, credits and discounts. “This group is going to deserve the Nobel Peace Prize,” said Mitchell Moss, a professor of urban policy and planning at New York University, noting that the pandemic had put a spotlight on people like health care workers who could deserve discounts or exemptions.

“There are categories that weren’t considered when this was approved in 2019,” he said.

What would happen to traffic that now goes through Manhattan is a concern in the other boroughs and in New Jersey. Representative Ritchie Torres, a Democrat from the Bronx, wrote on Twitter last week that he was for congestion pricing, “but any particular plan that diverts diesel truck traffic from Manhattan to the Bronx is unfair.” He said he did not want the Bronx “to become Manhattan’s dumping ground for air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.”

Gov. Phil Murphy of New Jersey has complained that congestion pricing would create what he called “double taxation” for commuters who already pay tolls at the Hudson River tunnels and the George Washington Bridge. Representative Josh Gottheimer, a Democrat from New Jersey, echoed that idea when he and Representative Nicole Malliotakis, a Republican from Staten Island, issued a statement opposing congestion pricing.

“Can you imagine a hardworking nurse or Uber driver from Jersey having to pay $23 a day on top of the $16 they pay to go over the G.W. Bridge — not to mention what it costs for parking and gas?” Gottheimer said. “Just read M.T.A. spelled backward and it tells you exactly how the M.T.A. looks at New Jersey right now: as their personal A.T.M.”


Expect a sunny day near 90. The evening will be partly cloudy, and temps will approach the low 70s.


In effect until Sept. 5 (Labor Day).

The latest New York news

Credit…Gabriela Bhaskar for The New York Times
  • De Blasio’s new venture: Bill de Blasio will become a visiting teaching fellow at Harvard in the fall.

  • Off-duty police officer attacked: Three men wanted in a score of crimes attacked an off-duty officer, police officials said. He was in critical condition.

Arts & Culture

  • Chelsea Manning as D.J.: Before she orchestrated the largest intelligence leak in U.S. history, Chelsea Manning was known to D.J. She shook off the cobwebs in Bushwick last week.

  • La MaMa’s season: For its 61st season, La MaMa Experimental Theater Club will present more than 40 productions from eight countries. Here’s some of what’s on the lineup.

  • Same old vintage? Try Newburgh: About two hours from New York City, the Newburgh Vintage Emporium stores are luring choosy shoppers with a less picked-over selection.

  • Passing of a lifelong film lover: Joanne Koch, the longtime head of the Film Society of Lincoln Center, died at 92.

After the primaries

Credit…Justin Lane/EPA, via Shutterstock

There were some surprises in primaries for Congress and the State Senate on Tuesday, votes that were delayed after aggressive redistricting by Democratic officials was invalidated by state courts and district lines had to be redrawn. Two mainstays of Manhattan politics — Representative Carolyn Maloney and Representative Jerrold Nadler — were forced to run against each other. I asked Nicholas Fandos, who covers New York politics, for a debriefing.

What do Tuesday’s results indicate about the direction of the Democratic Party in New York if not nationally?

Tuesday was a long night of mixed results for Democrats. There was outright pain: the loss of a powerful committee chair in Carolyn Maloney. There were signs of the resurgence of the moderate wing of the Democratic Party in Representative Sean Patrick Maloney’s commanding win over a rising star of the left.

And then there was an unexpected special election victory by Pat Ryan, a Democrat, in a Hudson Valley swing seat that gave a new breath of optimism for national Democratic leaders that this fall’s midterm elections might not be as punishing for their party as originally expected. Ryan made abortion rights a centerpiece of his campaign after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, and it appeared to motivate voters.

It wasn’t a great night for the progressives.

Certainly not at the congressional level, no. Sean Patrick Maloney easily dispatched Alessandra Biaggi, a state senator who ran hard to his left, in the lower Hudson Valley. Max Rose, an avowed centrist, easily won the Democratic primary for a Staten Island-based seat.

Then again, the left did do better in some key State Senate contests, despite active efforts by Mayor Eric Adams to stop some of their candidates.

What about the progressives’ strategy in the district in Brooklyn with more than a dozen candidates? There were three left-leaning candidates, who split the field.

Yes, the race in the 10th district connecting Lower Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn was another pain point for progressives.

Three of their candidates ended up splitting 60 percent of the vote, leaving Daniel Goldman, a wealthy former federal prosecutor, a lane to win with just 25 percent of the vote. Goldman is no centrist, but he is not a movement progressive, either.

Among the losers in that race was Representative Mondaire Jones, one of the first openly gay Black members of Congress. He moved to Brooklyn after Sean Patrick Maloney opted to run in what in essentially the district Jones now represents.

What about Carolyn Maloney? She lost to Nadler. Did the third candidate in the race take enough moderate votes from her to make a difference? And what does she do now?

This was one of the hardest-fought races in the state, between two seasoned former allies. In the end, Nadler ran away with it, more than doubling Maloney’s vote count. Suraj Patel, the third candidate, certainly siphoned votes away from Maloney, but fewer than Nadler’s margin of victory.

As for Maloney, it is hard not to see this as the end of a four-decade political career. She is 76 and has quite a record of accomplishment from 30 years in Congress to look back on. But she is surely disappointed today.


Like a native

Dear Diary:

I was new to the city, having just arrived from Wales to live with my wife, a native New Yorker, on the Upper West Side.

Yearning to fit in, I would listen enviously as she and her friends discussed the apparently endless combinations of ways — bus, subway, walking, taxi, Uber — to get somewhere. All I knew were the No. 1 and No. 2 lines.

One day, I got off the 1 at 86th Street and headed for our apartment at 90th and Broadway. A man and a woman approached me on the noisy, busy platform. They had worried looks.

“Excuse me,” the man said. “How do we get to Times Square?”

“Ah,” I said, “You are going uptown. You need to go downtown. Go up those stairs, cross the street and come back down to the other platform. Get a 1 train downtown to 42nd Street. That’s the Times Square stop.”

They thanked me and walked away.

I stood there, glowing with pride.

— Paul Stapleton

Illustrated by Agnes Lee. Send submissions here and read more Metropolitan Diary here.

Glad we could get together here. See you tomorrow. — J.B.

P.S. Here’s today’s Mini Crossword and Spelling Bee. You can find all our puzzles here.

Melissa Guerrero and Ed Shanahan contributed to New York Today. You can reach the team at [email protected].


Related Articles

Back to top button